The school within your catchment area is best for you.
We looked at the Premier Academy and on paper it sounds amazing but we also spoke to others who had personal experience of it and it wasn't positive from any of them plus the term dates are crazy. We are definitely avoiding that school now.
@Claire thanks for letting me know
I personally would look at the schools closest to you and choose the best one. It is so much more convenient to have their friends local, less of a daily commute and more part of the community